Savage Zen Athletics
Savage Zen Athletics
HomeBlueprintAuditDBTProgramsCoaching
Sign in

Evaluating Coaches and Gyms

Everyone wants something different from the personal services they hire. You probably have a goal or objective in mind when you order your coffee, call the yard mowing crew, go to the doctor, or hire a personal trainer.

For people who have made it a habit, nay, a “lifestyle”, to challenge physical limitations, ask intelligent questions, and establish high standards for success in all areas of life; you can become known as “a difficult customer.”

In reality, this merely flags the insecurities or lack of competence in the potential candidate you’re looking to hire — whether that’s a new martial arts gym, subcontractor, or consultant.

Competent people don’t mind answering questions, asking them, or acknowledging their limitations. That’s what “standing on business” really means.

a man in a black shirt writing on a clipboard
Photo by Marvin Cors on Unsplash

Preface:

When I’m marketing at a gym or to a new potential client, I start by saying:

"“I’m an individual design coach.”

Which invariably provokes the question:

“What does that mean?”

Simply enough, with some intended mystery, I reply:

“People pay me to train them and to listen. The work they put in and the conversations we have change them. Depending on their needs that might be physical fitness, psychotherapy, or martial arts.

That conversation bit is one of the fundamental elements I see missing from most “personal” services as an industry. Everyone is shouting (online) about how great they are and why you should hire them for X, Y, or Z.

In practice, this takes several forms, which I’m sure you’ve seen:

  • Commodification - dollars for time transactions (a race to the bottom).

  • Echo chambers - something becomes popular, everyone starts hocking it, presenting as chic and ingenious overrides actual creativity and problem solving.

  • Pseudo-Coaches - programmers, technicians, and cheerleaders (the service is about padding their resume, not helping you).

  • Culture erosion - we’re alone together, dissenting opinions are canceled, purity culture proliferates, and tribalism abounds.

David Fields calls this “wrong-side up thinking.” I talked about many of these grifter stereotypes in the article titled “Thinning the Herd.”

I designed this tool to help you audit whether or not a gym, coach, trainer, or other personal service is actually thinking “right-side up” and can deliver what you’re hoping to achieve via real interpersonal work.

For an example proxy, I will use the evaluation process I implement for actual CrossFit gyms. Also, rather than give you a link to a spreadsheet, PDF, or Google Form, I want you create something that’s important to you.

In fact, you could even run my website content and services through the same evaluation process!

If you do, please don’t hesitate to send me an email or leave a comment with the results!


Step 1:

The Centerpiece.

What do you want to get out of the experience? What is the central thing you are trying to achieve by interacting with this environment / person / business? What is it that you are actually forking over your hard earned money for?

If I’m buying cookies or coffee, there’s a certain way I like those things to taste and for them to be prepared. Some of that gets into Step 2, but the idea is that when I think about eating cookies or drinking coffee, I have a certain experience in mind.

There is a state of being I want to achieve. This also holds true for coaches, supervisors, dog trainers, tech devices, any kind of service or product.


Step 2:

Content Areas.

As alluded to in Step 1, there are certain elements that allow a service — that delivers the experience I’m seeking or problem I’m wanting solved — to be fulfilled or stifles that fulfillment.

In this template I’ll use a 3 x 3 model for Step 2 and Step 3, because it’s logical and visually appealing; but in reality this might vary slightly. The point is that we likely need more than one and less than five. Our assessment process needs to be effective and accurate, but not just in content, in it’s implementation.

So, let’s start with three categories that “allow or inhibit our success criteria.”

Example:

When dropping in to a CrossFit gym I, of course, want to get a workout, but I also want to be socially and intellectually engaged. In this example, the three categories I chose for success markers are:

  • Training (the actual workout)

  • Coaching (the delivery and instruction)

  • Business (vibe check)


Step 3:

Subjects.

Now we need to get a little more specific. This is where the supports hit the ground floor — the rubber meets the road.

For each support (Step 2) there are likely several factors that contribute to quality in that area. Again, you don’t have to be an “expert” in anything other than your particular tastes, goals, and desires (Step 1).

This also creates diversity (“deviance” in statistical terms) so that lacking quality or competency in one support sub-category can be compensated for elsewhere. In our CrossFit example, under the “Coaching” support, an individual might be very attentive, but have poor delivery (or vice versa).

Example:

Content Area 1: Training

  • Category 1a: Programming Intent

  • Category 1b: Skill Integration

  • Category 1c: Work Awareness


Step 4:

Grading Criteria.

Now we’re going to demand a lot of clarity, from ourselves. Not only does this make the assessment more “fair” for the subject(s), but it also serves as an integrity check for the evaluator.

First, a simple grading scale of 1 - 3 or 1 - 5 (higher being better) will suffice. This could be more granular (e.g. 1 - 10), but there’s a lot more cognitive friction in the evaluation process when applied across all of our “subjects” and “content areas.”

The clarity here comes from knowing exactly what a “5” looks like versus “4”. If there are gaps where you can’t quite differentiate that granularity, that’s fine. Having a clear picture of what “5”, “3”, and “1” looks like just mean you adjust the scores to “3”, “2”, and “1” respectively.

Regarding quality control, it helps to set the bar high here — no grade inflation. A mid score of 2/3 or 3/5 is “average”, it should be expected. On paper that registers as 60% - 66%, but it isn’t “failure.”

A score of 4/5 is clearly “above average” and conversely 2/5 is sub-par. Meanwhile, 5/5 is truly exceptional and should be rare. Likewise, someone has to really drop the ball to score 1/5.

Not only does this create a robust standard, but it also means that a coach or gym having an “off day” and losing any one or even two “points” isn’t going to blow the entire evaluation.

(3 content areas) x (3 subjects per content area) x (5 points per subject) = 45 total points. Each individual “point” is only 2.22% of the total score in this example.

Example:

Content Area 1: Training

  • Category 1a: Programming Intent

  • Category 1b: Skill Integration

  • Category 1c: Work Awareness

    • 1 - Endorphin trap.

    • 2 - Mechanical survival.

    • 3 - Score fixation / efficiency cues.

    • 4 - Pacing standards / interval specific.

    • 5 - True state awareness and arousal control.


Step 5:

Aggregate Scoring.

Now, with the raw data entered we can compute aggregate scores for comparison. This is best done with simple spreadsheet formulas, but you could of course do it manually on paper if desired.

A key assumption here is that all of our “content areas” and “subjects” are weighted equally. In the example, neither coaching, training, or business categories carry more weight or skew the overall score more than any other category.

This may not necessarily be true in your evaluation, but it keeps the process significantly more simple.

In our example we had three subject areas:

  • Training

  • Coaching

  • Business

Each had three subjects for evaluation. For each subject area, compute either the sum total of its “subjects” or mean average — however you’d like to compare them.

Example:

  • Training (3.00 average)

    • Subject 1a (programming intent): 4

    • Subject 1b (skill integration): 4

    • Subject 1c (work awareness): 1

  • Coaching (2.67 average)

    • Subject 2a: 3

    • Subject 2b: 3

    • Subject 2c: 2

  • Business (3.00 average)

    • Subject 3a: 3

    • Subject 3b: 4

    • Subject 3c: 2

  • Overall Score: 2.9 (58%)

The above example is real data from a real gym I visited. Overall they were just below average. What’s more is that the criteria we established creates a very clear picture.

For example, regarding “Training”, the programming, skill integration, and warm up were very good, but when it came to the actual work it was a total music-blasting, minimal-cue, endorphin trap — even though “RPE 8” was written on the whiteboard.


Step 6:

X-Factors and Subjectivity.

In statistical and professional literature, this would be the “disclosures and limitations” section of our publication. For personal purposes though, it’s sufficient to say that there are things the numbers and data miss.

Maybe it was my regularly scheduled cookie-sampling, or cross training, day and I knew I didn’t sleep well the night before, or that a bad driver cut me off in traffic, or a random storm knocked out power on the bakery / gym’s entire block.

Maybe, in the same class, one coach sucked and another was great?

Would I be willing to put up with crass coaching if the programming and training results were outstanding? To what degree?

The example used in this tool was a 3x3 matrix — a 9-item inventory. If you’re looking for something even more simple, ask yourself:

What are the top 5 things I want from my training experience at this gym?

The same process follows. Each of those five items gets a 5-point scoring system with clear behavioral and experiential indicators.

Two of those items might be “cost” of (gym dues) and “distance” from home or work. Something else to consider is that on a spreadsheet your gym dues (cost) and commute (distance) might get weighted evenly, but the reality of behavioral friction is different.

How much would you (effectively) pay yourself to make sure you go to the gym everyday because it’s on your way home or just down the street?

These are the kinds of things that are useful to track in a subjective notes section. They also help us clarify and refine our own ideas, goals, and expectations because we are (hopefully) explaining why a certain grade was given instead of another if the point was on the line.

Example:

This is real line note from a real gym owner (not the same as the one in Step 5):

Former power lifter. Curious about BJJ and wrestling. Good business practices. Stuck in programming and coaching dogma — afraid to implement what he likes over HQ’s recommendations.

As mentioned above, I’m not opposed to feedback. In fact, I’d strongly encourage you to run my content and materials through this same evaluation process and post the results to a comment — or private email!

What’s important to you probably isn’t exactly the same as what’s important to me. The better I can learn what people are wanting and expecting, the better I can get at the services I provide.

Conversations change people. So, let’s start talking!

Looking for a guided and personalized approach to your fitness training that builds a better vessel for achieving physical outcomes?

Book a Coaching Appointment

Or stay up to date for free with the Savage Zen Athletics Newsletter!

Updated: 2026.11.15

Savage Zen Athletics

A mind and body under development. The official journal of Onward Counseling & Training.

  • About
  • Archive
  • Recommendations
  • Sitemap
© 2026 Austin Haedicke · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.