Commodity Trap
The health and fitness race to the bottom.
The health and fitness industry has an economic problem, inflation is more out of control than the national debt. I don’t mean to say that health and fitness as practices are problematic, quite the opposite. It’s the “industrial complex” and consumerism that have pervaded the practice that’s insidious and predatory.
In many ways, this is not different than any other “industrial complex” in the United States — military, medical, educational, pharmaceutical, etc. Now, before anyone chimes in about trainers or therapists “needing to keep people sick”; I’ll note that the last time I checked there was no shortage of people struggling in these areas.
This is much different than a zero-sum “commodity” transaction. Therapy, for example, does not work like a gumball machine where you put your money in, turn the knob, and a magical pill — or 6-minute-abs — are suddenly dispensed.
Let’s take an example from another industry. Fast food is a commodity. You expect “more for your money.” You also don’t have the option to cancel your order. You point to something on a menu (or shelf), pay, receive, leave. There is no relationship.
Compare this to a “sit down” restaurant. You order, receive, eat, are serviced, then pay; and that pay is commensurate with the service you received. It is entirely dependent on the relationship. Further, abusing this relationship by harassing the waitstaff or cancelling orders sours the experience both directions.
Another hot-button issue, cancellation fees, illustrates what type of “commodity” service “consumers” are expecting — the language itself is foretelling.
If I am a trainer that is paid by the hour, how do I handle cancellations for a client’s minor emergency, like a flat tire? From the provider’s perspective, how do I also explain to my own children that they don’t get dinner tonight because Bob had a flat tire and missed his appointment?
If I’m operating within a “fast food” model, the client will be insulted that I charged a fee on top of their already inconvenient flat tire expense. They paid and did not receive what they expected.
But, what they did receive was confirmation of the trainer’s integrity. Let’s say that missed session cost “Bob” $100. Exactly how many sessions did you think $100 was going to buy, and what magical outcome did you expect would be achieved at the end of those sessions?
If $100 is really going to break the bank, then I have to ask, “I know you’re a smart person Bob, and know there are dozens of other trainers in town who charge less, some who you’ve worked with before. Why are you standing in front of, or on a call, with me?”
In this example, the picture gets even worse if the hypothetical trainer is treated like a waiter — paid sub-minimum wage to be on the floor and expected to be indignantly bossed around in order to accumulate tips or commission based on customer satisfaction
So far I’ve talked a lot about the provider / industry side of the equation, but the client / athlete is ultimately under served here as well. Has anyone really left McDonald’s or Taco Bell (particularly after midnight) and said:
“That was a great idea! I’m really glad I did that.”
We all know the answer. That was a decision made for the sake of convenience, not satisfaction. Yet billions of dollars in advertising are spent to convince you otherwise… “bah bah bop bop bop baaah, I’m lovin’ it!”
The wider we cast this net, the more problematic the whole issue becomes. Plug “marketing for fitness coaches” into any search engine and you’ll likely be prompted with all kinds of courses and how-tos espousing the same generic content you yourself are sick of seeing.
Imagine how that looks and feels to the person who expects their trainer to take the session and the project just as seriously as the athlete? Isn’t that what it means to be a “professional” anyway?
If your “brand” is AI-generated ad campaigns featuring video templates of folks mid-rep, light sweat, with marginal load and smiling faces, I’m not interested. Maybe there are folks who are, but that’s not who I’m interested in working with or for.
Let’s also not forget the amount of “performative suffering” that occurs online. Be sure to set up a ring light before you read your divorce decree, or after you botch a surgery… human resources and your state licensing board are going to want to take a look at that!
I’m certainly not trying to tell you to “suffer in silence.” I’m saying that real people always want real results, which seems increasingly rare. Many people nowadays are much more concerned with looking like a thing than they are being capable of doing things.
Novice athletes and trainees almost always start with an end goal in mind — they’d like to look a certain way or achieve a certain task. However, something the fitness industry (both providers and patrons) can learn from clinical counseling is that the process — when it’s effective — often works in reverse.
People come asking for help, thinking they already know what the problem is, and want someone to tell them what to do about it. That’s commodity thinking. The reality is that you probably already know what you need to do. The real work is uncovering the myriad of nuance as to where the problem came from and what’s stopping you from doing what you know you need or would benefit from.
I’m not going to lie and tell you that I’ve never dropped the ball or made a mistake and rightly pissed off and lost clients. Certainly, not every corporate evaluation I’ve gotten has been star-spangled. What I can tell you, with absolute certainty, is that no peer or client review of mine is going to say “great value for the price” or “got what I paid for.”
Evaluating Coaches and Gyms
Everyone wants something different from the personal services they hire. You probably have a goal or objective in mind when you order your coffee, call the yard mowing crew, go to the doctor, or hire a personal trainer.


Discussion about this post